On rare occasions a few of Carl Barks' published comic book story drawings from the Western Publishing series would graphically deviate a little from the ones he originally drew. There could be several reasons for the alterations, but in essence they can be divided into three main groups: 1. redrawings that Barks did himself for various reasons, 2. redrawings or deletions as a result of Western requesting Barks to redraw or delete one or more panels, or 3. redrawings that Western made without Barks' knowledge. This page will restrict itself to examples from the third group*.
It is entirely plausible that Barks often deplored the redrawings Western executed (who would not be a bit miffed when one's hard work is questioned?), but there can be no doubt that Western did so in order to better an already excellent product. To what extent they succeeded is up to your own judgement upon having browsed the examples below...
* This site has a variety of pages covering the two first-mentioned groups. Examples are: THE ALTERATIONS, THE CENSORSHIP, THE HALLOWEEN FILM, THE OVERRULINGS, THE REJECTIONS, THE SHELVED COVERS, THE SURVIVING ARTWORK, THE UNFINISHED, and THE UNPUBLISHED.
FRONT COVERS
![]() FC0353 - October 1951 For reasons unknown Western did not like Barks' version of the nephews so a staff artist redrew them. |
Barks specifically requested that the angry Donald was shown with red pupils. Western did not comply. |
![]() WDCS142 - July 1952 Barks originally drew the cover with some background which Western chose to delete. |
The many fingerprints on the bath towel were added by Western. |
![]() WDCS160 - January 1954 Western redrew Donald's face in order to make him look sicker. |
![]() WDCS174 - March 1955 Western redrew Donald's head in a clumsy way. |
![]() DD46 - March 1956 The nephews' faces were redrawn by Western. |
The nephews' faces were redrawn by Western. |
The Donald gag was partially drawn by another artist. |
The front cover was drawn with full backgrounds by Barks but deleted by Western. |
![]() DD106 - March 1966 The nearest nephew was drawn dancing by Barks. Western redrew him bouncing instead. |
![]() U$64 - July 1966 Barks drew the cover without backgrounds. Western added a few sketchy pagodas. |
PANELS
DISFIGURED ART |
||||||||
|
STRETCHED PANEL |
||||||||
|
COMPRESSED PAGES |
||||||||
|
ADDED HALOES |
||||||||
|
REMOVED PINCENEZ |
||||||||
|
REMOVED DOTS |
||||||||
|
ALTERED ENDING |
||||||||
|
FOREIGN REDRAWINGS It frequently happened that Barks' panels were altered in different ways abroad. The most common changes were the shape of the speech balloons that often had to be redrawn in order to contain the more or less lengthy dialogue in a certain country's language, but other - and more severe - changes occurred as well. Examples from the Danish publisher Egmont can be seen HERE. |
http://www.cbarks.dk/THEREDRAWINGS.htm | Date 2009-09-18 |